Is killing your child in the name of family honour ever justified?
Yes
2.4% (9 votes)
Unsure
0.3% (1 votes)
No
97.3% (362 votes)
Comments
there are a few situations where the taking of life is justified, even the right thing to do, but this is DEFINATELY not one of them. Family honour takes second place to the preservation of life.
Posted: 3 August 2010 - 12:41pm — luceEnd
Killing your own child would require a heinous crime to justify it. However, there is one example (from cinema) that might fit the bill. This is the 1962 Yul Brynner flick Taras Bulba. In the ending of this picture, the Yul Brynner character (chief of the Cossacks besieging the Polish city) takes it up himself to execute his son (played by Tony Curtis) for helping the enemy (because he fell in love with a Polish girl).
The manner of the execution is significant. The Yul Brynner character dismisses his entourage with a glance. The entourage figure out what is going on and ride off leaving the father to do what is required to salvage the family honour alone.
The Brynner character tells his son to "take off that Polish helmet" and shoots him through the heart.
Interested in supporting St James Ethics Centre by volunteering with us? Learn more about current volunteering roles available at the Centre.
Support our work!
St James Ethics Centre is a fully independent not-for-profit and relies heavily upon financial and in-kind support from individuals and organisations. If ethics matters to you, please support our work.
Read about ethics
Want to learn more about ethics and read about ethics-related issues? Visit our Ethics Articles section, where you'll find hundreds of articles about a very diverse array of topics. Read more.
latest ethics poll
Comments
there are a few situations where the taking of life is justified, even the right thing to do, but this is DEFINATELY not one of them. Family honour takes second place to the preservation of life.
Posted: 3 August 2010 - 12:41pm — luceEnd
Killing your own child would require a heinous crime to justify it. However, there is one example (from cinema) that might fit the bill. This is the 1962 Yul Brynner flick Taras Bulba. In the ending of this picture, the Yul Brynner character (chief of the Cossacks besieging the Polish city) takes it up himself to execute his son (played by Tony Curtis) for helping the enemy (because he fell in love with a Polish girl).
The manner of the execution is significant. The Yul Brynner character dismisses his entourage with a glance. The entourage figure out what is going on and ride off leaving the father to do what is required to salvage the family honour alone.
The Brynner character tells his son to "take off that Polish helmet" and shoots him through the heart.
Posted: 9 August 2010 - 11:22am — perseus